Rieger Creek Lodge logo white
November 10, 2026

Best Shotgun for Pheasant Hunting: Gauge, Choke and Shells by Season

Quick answer

The best shotgun for pheasant hunting is a 12 or 20 gauge you can carry all day and shoot well, whether that is an over-and-under, a semi-auto or a pump. Pair it with Number 5 shot and match your choke to the season: improved cylinder early, modified in the middle of the season, and improved modified to full in late season when birds flush farther out. At Rieger Creek you can skip hauling a gun entirely, since 12 and 20 gauge rentals and ammunition are part of the package.

Picking the best shotgun for pheasant hunting gets more debate around the lodge fire than almost anything else. The honest answer is simpler than most people make it. The right gun is the one that fits you, swings naturally and does not wear you out by the third field. The choke and the shell you put through it matter just as much, and those change with the season. Here is how our guides think about all three, from the Rieger Creek Hunt Planner and seventeen-plus seasons of watching roosters flush in South Dakota.

12 gauge or 20 gauge: the best shotgun for pheasant hunting starts here

Both work, and both show up in our fields every week. Our Hunt Planner recommends a 12 or 20 gauge as the best shotgun for pheasant hunting, and the choice comes down to what you value more on a long day of walking.

  • 20 gauge. Lighter to carry, easier on the shoulder, and plenty for roosters inside normal range. It is now the most popular upland gauge in the country. In Project Upland’s North American Upland Hunting Survey, 46 percent of upland hunters said the 20 gauge is their go-to.
  • 12 gauge. More shot in the air and more reach. It earns its keep in late season, when birds flush wild and shots stretch out. Around 28 percent of hunters in that same survey prefer it.
  • 28 gauge and .410. A 28 gauge in experienced hands can work early in the season. A .410 is a tough tool for a South Dakota rooster, and we do not recommend it for a pheasant trip.

Over-and-under, semi-auto or pump

Any reliable action can be the best shotgun for pheasant hunting. What matters is that you know your gun and it fits you. Here is how the common choices stack up for pheasant hunting.

Action Why hunters like it Keep in mind
Over-and-under Balanced, simple to unload between fields, two chokes on hand Two shots, and it is usually the heaviest to carry
Semi-auto Softer recoil and a third shot Keep it clean in the cold so it cycles
Pump Dependable in any weather and easy on the budget Practice the follow-up shot before your trip

For what it is worth, over-and-unders are the favorite among upland hunters nationally, at about 46 percent in the Project Upland survey, followed by side-by-sides and semi-autos.

The best choke for pheasant hunting, by season

This is where most hunters can make the biggest difference without buying a new gun. Even the best shotgun for pheasant hunting patterns poorly with the wrong choke. Birds act differently as the season goes on, and the choke should change with them.

When Choke Why
September to mid October Improved cylinder (modified works too) Full cover, birds hold tight, most flushes inside thirty yards
Late October to mid November Modified Birds get smarter and flushes get less predictable
Late November through January Improved modified to full Birds flush wild, fly hard, and shots are longer

Shooting an over-and-under? Run the more open choke in the bottom barrel for the first shot and the tighter choke on top for the bird that is already moving away. If you are coming in late season, our late season pheasant hunting guide covers what December and January really look like.

Shot size and shells for pheasants

Number 5 shot is our standard for pheasants all season, and it is what we stock at the lodge. It carries enough energy for a rooster without tearing up the bird. A few things to know beyond that:

  • Early season. Standard field loads in 2 3/4 inch are plenty for close, holding birds.
  • Late season. Our guides recommend heavier loads and copper-plated shot for the long ones, and a 3-inch shell helps on birds that flush wild.
  • Some hunters go up or down a size. 4s for late season reach, 6s early. Number 5 covers most days well.
  • Hunting public land on your own? Some public areas in South Dakota require nontoxic shot. Check the rules with South Dakota Game, Fish & Parks before you go.

Whatever gun you pick, the best shotgun for pheasant hunting is the one you have actually shot. A few rounds of sporting clays or trap before your trip will do more for your bag than a new barrel.

Bring your own or rent one at the lodge

The best shotgun for pheasant hunting might be the one already waiting at the lodge. You are welcome to bring your own gun. If you would rather not travel with one, shotgun rentals in 12 or 20 gauge are available at Rieger Creek, and ammunition, a shell vest, and eye and ear protection are included in your hunt. There is a gun cleaning station with tools and oil at the lodge, and every locker has its own boot dryer. See what else is covered on our rates page, and get the full gear list in our South Dakota pheasant hunting packing guide.

Ready to put it to use?

Call or text Christine at 605-845-8851 to talk dates, or send us a note and we will get right back to you.

Plan your hunt

Best shotgun for pheasant hunting FAQ

What is the best shotgun for pheasant hunting?

A 12 or 20 gauge that fits you and that you can carry comfortably all day. Over-and-unders, semi-autos and pumps all work well. The 20 gauge is lighter and now the most popular upland gauge, while the 12 gauge gives you more reach for late season birds.

What choke is best for pheasants?

It depends on the time of year. Use improved cylinder early in the season when birds hold tight, modified from late October into mid November, and improved modified to full in late season when birds flush farther out.

What size shot is best for pheasant?

Number 5 shot is the standard for pheasants in both 12 and 20 gauge. Some hunters use 6s early in the season and 4s late, but 5s cover most days well.

Do I need to bring my own shotgun to Rieger Creek?

No. Shotgun rentals in 12 or 20 gauge are available at the lodge, and ammunition is included in the package. You are welcome to bring your own gun if you prefer.

Gauge and action preferences cited from Project Upland’s North American Upland Hunting Survey. Choke and shell guidance comes from the Rieger Creek Hunt Planner and our guides. Hunting rules are set by South Dakota Game, Fish & Parks, confirm the latest at gfp.sd.gov.


Ready to Plan Your Hunt?

Fill out the Plan Your Hunt form to share a few details about your party, preferred dates, and hunt goals. Prefer to talk first? Call or text Christine. She’s the owner and the friendly voice that makes planning your trip feel easy from the very beginning.

Get the Free Hunt Planner

The licensing untangled, the dates that matter, what to pack, and how a day really runs out here. Everything to plan your hunt, from the guides at Rieger Creek.

Planning a Group Hunt?

A free guide built for whoever's doing the organizing. What all-inclusive really means, when to book, and seven questions to ask any lodge before you commit.
Coming Soon
Family owned. Private guided hunts. Five generations on the land. South Dakota pheasant hunting the way it was meant to be.
Catch us on
Rieger Creek LLC 2026